Wednesday, December 3, 2008

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

An observation on granularity

Integrating the Macro and Micro Processes ™ -- An observation on granularity of objectives

Many times, well meant initiatives fail not being communicated at the right level of granularity.

Consider this as an example,

Executive management states a strategic goal for the firm:

"Increase market penetration to 100%."

Although this goal is clear and may be communicated to a wide audience, it gets lost as it gets closer and closer to people performing the day to day work. The strategic objective may be seen as lofty and "pie in the sky".


An IT director may say:

"How does that affect me???? I am trying to run an IT organization with a strapped budget where 80% of the money is dedicated to maintaining legacy systems with huge licensing fees and infrastructure cost! The number one objective should be: change the ratio of maintenance from 80% to 20% in 5 years. This will leave 80% for developing new capabilities!!!"


An IT manager may say:

"Increase market share, how can I worry about that. I already have resource issues. I have been trying to get requisitions through for new talent, but the money always gets zapped because some part of our systems collapse and need fixing. The technology is old, but what can I do. And, when there finally is some relief where we can do new things, I end up getting consultants in to do the work then leave me with more "stuff" to maintain! My permanent staff really hates this, because the consultants get to do the "fun stuff" while they have to stay in their trenches putting out fires!

I think the initiative should be: "slow down the flow of work, and dedicate money for training my existing staff with new capabilities"


A senior IT staff member may say:

I want to lead my people and mentor them, but I am constantly getting de-railed by my senior management. Why did they put me in a senior position in the first place if this always gets overridden by my boss. I know what we need to do, but I am never given the time or authority to prove it. I think the initiative should be: empower senior staff members.


And, the person in the trenches may say:

I have heard the promised of training over and over again each time a consultant comes in. I think the initiative should be: allow workers to take classes in whatever subject they want and allow time to play with the new technology so the knowledge will stick.


Aren't they all saying the same thing, but from different levels of granularity?


We can better this archetype by:
1) link all projects to strategy;
2) have different levels of heirarchy / granularity.


You would ideally end up with:
Charters at the executive level;
Charters at the segment level that link initiatives to the executive level;
Charters at the business level that link initiatives to the segment and executive level;
Charters at the functional level that link initiatives to the business level as well as segment and exective;
Charters at the personal level linking to the other levels as well.


This would require:
1) a process with governance
2) centralized (yet distributed) information
3) updates at different paces depending upon how "lofty" the goal may be


Dale

Copyright © and trademark ™ 2008 Dale Chalfant. All Rights Reserved.